Tilley's Pizza House - Beloit, Wisconsin

Ashley Y.

Went here on a Saturday afternoon and it was nice a place. The population who were present was mostly older but that didn’t bother me. The waitress was very friendly and the place was clean, which I appreciated.

I decided to get a “thick” crust pizza and it was just okay. Nothing memorable if I’m being honest. I also ordered cheese curds as an appetizer and they were fine. Standard cheese curds again. I wasn’t a huge fan of the marinara sauce. The rating of the place really comes down to if I would want to eat there again, and it truly was not memorable enough to go back with what I had ordered.

Alexiana G.

Food was good, but when we went over to the bar to get a few drinks the bartender was EXTREMELY rude. My boyfriend asked how she was doing and she just replied, GOOD, what do you want?

Then she goes over to other people and are super nice.
Our server was nice though.
Bartender was 👎

Jenni A.

Good pizza at a reasonable price. Service was decent too, despite how busy the place was.

Scotty B.

I hadn't been to Tilley's in a long time, but I had been to the "new" facility. A friend came to town and we were looking for a place to eat and I suggested Tilley's. The pizza is still incredible the way I remember it!

Mary S.

Fantastic pizza. Love the crust and sauce. Husband loved his burger. Good service and reasonable prices. Hadn't been here in decades as I'm not in Beloit anymore, but will make the drive again.

Mallory S.

We loved our food. Only thing we wished for was wishing our fries were salted after pulling out of the oil so it sticks to it better, and our lemonade and raspberry tea a little sweeter. First time here so the two different doors (one to a area with booths and tables, and the other a bar with booths) and no workers were in the booth/table area, and there were no signs to direct people so they know, so it confused us so we didn't know which area we were supposed to go in to be seated until a worker in the bar told us and then when the waitress came she let us know we could sit wherever. We enjoyed the quiet seating area. We recommend the Prime rib sandwich(if you ask for the cheese from the poor boy sandwich to be added to it, it would be even better, also recommend the grilled cheese sandwich. The server was very nice and friendly. I do wish there were photos of the food in the menu though. We are both autistic and are visual processors so photos help us alot with choosing meals because new places, and not knowing what the food looks like can be overwhelming, and dealing with restrictive food intake disorder (RFID) it's hard to just pick foods we can't see and have never tried there because every place cooks theirs different.

Rick S.

First time at this establishment picking up pizzas for a customer. They told me they were very good a very different style, less sauce. But they and I liked them. Very organized. Will be back

Augustina C.

We got the "Broaster Chicken" was burnt and so dry. No flavor. The grease is old or not changed.
Never have I had such dry disgusting chicken. We will never get it there again and would never recommend anyone else to.