Italian Dreams Pizza & Pasta - Sycamore, Illinois

Courtney M.

This place is a taco pizza lovers dream! Although I’ve never had anything bad from here. It’s comfort food and just good food all together. Bonus points that the owner is the sweetest man and truly appreciates every customer that comes in and makes that known. He’s always there working and helping his employees. Better than all the chains. Do yourself a favor and visit!

Jeff A.

What a GREAT place! I am always greeted by name and a smile. The owner is a hard working person who takes time to chat with people picking up orders. The food is delicious and well packed for the ride home. My favorite are the Italian beefs, but the pizza is also incredible. They are very popular so keep that in mind when ordering on game day. A true east side gem.

DoorDash W. S.

*Review is for other Door Dash drivers*

Great place to pick up from. Food is usually ready to go when you get there and the owner is super friendly if you get to talk to him. If the order fits in your requirements for pay/tip…definitely pick up from here.

As a customer? Been going here for years. Great pizza and soups!

Shannon M.

I have lived in Sycamore for about 18 months. My heat failed on a very cold night and I mentioned to the service man that I would love some good soup to keep me warm. Cream of Chicken rice to be specific. ( I grew up in Oak Lawn and IYKYK) he immediately told me I had to get it from Italian Dreams. As a former South Sider himself, I trusted his judgment and and immediately placed an order. I was given great service and when I got there the owner gave me another order because " it's the end of the day and why should I throw it away" Now, was it as good as ya-ya's no, because its not the same soup. But it was amazing.
flash forward, I have been under the weather and I decided soup would do the trick and it was Thursday so Cream of Chicken from ID was the perfect option. I decided to try something else. I got the Lasagna. Boy was that an unexpected treat! so much of it, meatballs,
the soup and bread included for less than $15?
I didn't phone ahead and it was a rainy cold night. The owner told me to wait in my car and he carried it to me. He has been so friendly! and gone above and beyond. It's the simple gestures that make a difference.
I don't know if this is a hidden gem or it just was to me because I am so new to the area. But it shouldn't be hidden. I highly recommend getting your next carry out from Italian Dreams

Patti C.

So sad to have to write a bad review on our most favorite pizza place. The last 2 times we ordered they did not get it correct. But tonight the western bbq pizza was not good. Only a dribble of bbq sauce and just dry and bland. My husband's rib dinner was dry and bland as well. The prices are off the chart now. Over a 100 dollars for a full slab of ribs, large pizza and medium pizza. Sooo disappointed. I actually called to talk to management and that did not go well. They've been our favorite slurge pizza for many many years. Back to Rosatis

Brittany R.

Called to place an order for delivery just before they opened, which I didn’t realize until after the fact was very pleased today with the service over the phone, the promptness and the help. Very friendly.

Steven D.

Majorly underwhelmed by this pizza 🍕 but I’m willing to give it a second chance sometime down the road. The team that handled the order was SUPER kind, friendly, and helpful. I ordered on a Friday night and they were excellent in making sure the pizza was ready for pickup at the selected time.

However the pizza itself, despite the picture, was not good...not even close. At the end of the day, I’d give the pizza a 5.2 out of 10. The crust and undercarriage were undercooked pretty significantly, which is strange because it was a thin crust pie. It tasted like hot cafeteria pizza, literally nothing special about the sauce & herbs mix, plus the cheese blend was fairly forgettable.

By comparison, the pizza that I was served was slightly better than good gas station pizza.

Barbara C.

They have the Best pizza in town awesome sauce!I couldn't keep Lily away! I highly recommend the clam chowder on Fridays! I have ordered from there 2-3 times a week i have now stopped going when i had a problem i asked the owner to call me i never got a call then i waited there fot 25 min waiting to talk to him the next time i ordered he never found it a priority to talk to me i said plz let him know i am now even more upset being kept waiting and being ignored abd my dinner getting cold have him call i am still waiting he never called me till this day he lost very great customers! I wont be back ill be going elsewhere a few times a week!!! They went from 5stars to 1 very disappointed! !!...