Coffee Mill Diner - Smithton, Illinois

Coffee Mill Diner

Coffee Mill Diner, located at 101 N Main St Unit 2, Smithton, IL 62285, is a delightful coffee shop that offers a range of services including delivery, takeout, dine-in, and a family-friendly atmosphere. Established in the heart of Smithton, this charming diner has quickly become a local favorite, with an impressive 4.6 out of 5 stars rating based on 65 reviews on Google My Business.

Specialties: Coffee Mill Diner is renowned for its exceptional coffee, along with a delectable selection of breakfast options. Their cozy ambiance and commitment to customer satisfaction make them a top choice for both locals and visitors alike.

Other points of interest: In addition to their excellent coffee and breakfast offerings, Coffee Mill Diner provides a welcoming environment for families with children. The staff at this diner are known for their friendly demeanor and efficiency, ensuring a pleasant dining experience for all patrons.

Opinions: Reviewers have consistently praised Coffee Mill Diner for its pleasant atmosphere, delicious food, and prompt service. Many have expressed their surprise at discovering such a hidden gem in Smithton, with some even making special trips from neighboring areas just to enjoy a meal at this delightful diner.

For example: One satisfied customer raved about their experience, stating, 'Really surprising find, worth the short drive out. Lots of seating with a cozy atmosphere. Staff was just so nice. Food came out very quick and was pretty good, first place I've ever been that gave you doughnut holes on the side of a lunch meal and I loved it. Bacon was a little overcooked but still edible. Will be back soon.'

To contact Coffee Mill Diner, you can reach them via phone at 84165356 or by visiting their location at 101 N Main St Unit 2, Smithton, IL 62285.

👍 Reviews of Coffee Mill Diner

Aaron S.

5/5

Really surprising find, worth the short drive out. Lots of seating with a cozy atmosphere. Staff was just so nice. Food came out very quick and was pretty good, first place I've ever been that gave you doughnut holes on the side of a lunch meal and I loved it. Bacon was a little overcooked but still edible. Will be back soon.

The G. S.

5/5

I mostly come here for my wife. She loves their turtle and Maple with bacon donuts. To be honest the donuts are a little bit too sugary for me and literally hurt my teeth. I brought a buddy with me this time as this was my second visit and he literally inhaled his donuts within 5 minutes of leaving the store. Nice place with a clean and peppy interior. The best donuts go quickly

M K.

3/5

Love the donuts, but wish they would box them immediately when you order. We waited more than twenty minutes for just donuts after checking out on a relatively slow morning. We understand waiting for food & drinks to be prepared- but I’ve never been to another donut shop that made you sit & wait for something sitting in the display case.

Christine O.

3/5

Stopped in for donuts. Relatively long wait to get anyone’s attention, placed order, paid, then we’re asked to step back so she could wait on the guy behind us. (Why did she not bag our donuts and send us on our way? We were there first!) While we waited in the background, we noticed that our shoes were sticking to the floor. Perhaps they need to mop?
The donuts tasted fine, but they are really unattractive—it was hard to choose by appearance.
I wish I could be more complimentary—it’s a really cute, small town place, but …meh.

Matt P.

5/5

Love this place. Jeff the owner was very accommodating to my whole family. We will definitely be going back often. Donuts are fresh, coffee was exceptional, and the sandwiches are awesome.

michelle D.

5/5

Our first visit to the Smithton location was a success! The drive thru moved quickly and vehicles were being directed to the park after placing orders. The wait was reasonable for hot fresh sandwiches and coffee drinks we ordered, less than 10 minutes. My husband got the waffle sandwich and I had sandwich envy! The waffle tasted very much like funnel cake batter and was very light compared to a traditional waffle. Also, the waffle sandwich was huge, so bring your appetite!

Sarah H.

1/5

2 of our 5 drinks weren’t what I ordered. The others hardly tasted like coffee. I waited at the counter for almost 5 minutes before being acknowledged by the staff. Even though they all turned around to look at me when i came in. My drink had an eyelash in it 🤢 I wont be coming back.

Marcus S.

5/5

I was very impressed with this coffee house. A very impressive looking place in a such a small town. I would definitely spend a lot of time in there if I lived in the area. Very cozy. Donuts were very good, and price was good.