Wild Pony Coffee Co. - Evansville, Wyoming

Wild Pony Coffee Co.: A Detailed Overview

Wild Pony Coffee Co. is a highly-regarded coffee shop located in the charming town of Evansville, Wyoming. Situated at 6985 Nugget, this establishment has quickly gained a loyal following due to its commitment to quality coffee, a welcoming atmosphere, and attentive service. The company’s dedication to providing a pleasant experience for all patrons is evident in its various amenities and operational practices. It’s a place where one can truly savor a moment of relaxation and enjoy expertly crafted beverages.

Location and Accessibility

The address for Wild Pony Coffee Co. is 6985 Nugget, Evansville, WY 82636. This location offers convenient access and ample parking, including a free parking lot, as well as free street parking options. Furthermore, the business is designed to be wheelchair accessible, boasting a wheelchair accessible parking lot and a wheelchair accessible restroom, demonstrating a commitment to inclusivity and accessibility for all customers. Its central location within Evansville makes it easily reachable for both locals and tourists alike.

Specialties and Offerings

Wild Pony Coffee Co.’s primary focus is, of course, serving exceptional coffee. They pride themselves on a great coffee selection, catering to a wide range of tastes and preferences. Beyond classic espresso drinks, they offer a diverse array of teas, ensuring there’s something to please every palate. The establishment’s menu demonstrates a thoughtful curation of beverages, emphasizing both traditional favorites and creative seasonal specials. Recent customer feedback indicates a particular fondness for their brown sugar shaken espresso, frequently lauded as the best they’ve ever experienced. The company also offers takeout and delivery services, providing flexibility for customers who prefer to enjoy their coffee at home or on the go. Notably, they accept credit cards and offer the option for reservations, further enhancing the customer experience.

Customer Feedback and Reputation

Wild Pony Coffee Co. has garnered positive attention within the Evansville community, evidenced by 30 reviews on Google My Business. The average opinion is a solid 4 out of 5, reflecting a generally satisfied customer base. Reviews consistently highlight the quality of the coffee and the attentiveness of the baristas. Several patrons mention the knowledgeable staff, who are praised for their ability to create custom drinks and accommodate specific requests. One recurring theme is the speed and accuracy with which orders are prepared, suggesting a well-organized and efficient operation. The atmosphere is described as casual and trendy, appealing to a diverse clientele, including tourists seeking a local experience. The variety of beverages, coupled with the friendly service, contributes to a consistently enjoyable experience for visitors and regulars alike. The ability to request unique drink combinations, as highlighted by one reviewer’s experience with the non-menu brown sugar espresso, speaks to the staff’s willingness to go above and beyond for their customers.

Additional Points of Interest

Beyond its core offerings, Wild Pony Coffee Co. provides a comfortable and inviting space for customers to relax and socialize. The restroom is readily available and easily accessible. The shop's casual and trendy vibe makes it a popular spot for meetings, quiet study, or simply enjoying a cup of coffee. The establishment’s popularity suggests a strong connection with the local community and a reputation for quality and service. The fact that they offer a diverse selection of teas complements their coffee offerings, catering to a broader range of preferences. The convenient access to parking and the accepting of reservations further contribute to a hassle-free and enjoyable visit.

👍 Reviews of Wild Pony Coffee Co.

Rayge87

5/5

Great coffee and reasonably priced!
The barista was attentive and knowledgeable.

Jessica P.

5/5

Best brown sugar shaken expresso, I’ve ever had! Asked for something that wasn’t on the menu, the barista made it perfectly!

Squeaky S.

5/5

I've been here a few times, first had an Irish Mocha, and most recently the February special "Lovers Mocha" (I can't remember what else I've had).
Both were good, and the coffees have always been made quickly and correctly.

Definitely will be stopping by again.

Marissa S.

1/5

Whoever was working the morning shift at about 9:40 AM on December 3rd 2024 was extremely rude, didn’t make mine or my mothers drink right, and gave us both wrong size and when we corrected her she threw down the cups and threw a hissy fit. Do better!!! Don’t hire people that don’t want to do customer service!

Lindsey W.

5/5

I have to get better about recognizing amazing service, so here it is…. First off, I myself have worked in the coffee industry for 15 years. I recently decided to take a break and drive long distance deliveries for a while. I am so excited to try different shops around Wyoming and Nebraska. This one got my attention with great customer service and a delicious cup of coffee!! I have worked with many personalities in this industry myself as a manager and Brandalynn has something the industry needs more of. She held a great conversation and seemed happy to be working a busy day!! Bitter baristas make bitter coffee. Sorry but it’s true! lol She also mentioned she was only two weeks into her coffee career and my coffee was perfect! (oat milk pistachio latte) Props to the manager and their training!! I know that level of care and skill came from somewhere! I drive through town often and will absolutely be back for more! I purchased a bag of dark roast from Snowy Elk Coffee Co. as well that I can’t wait to brew! 😋 I am sucker for trying locally roasted beans and will update.

Thank you for a delicious pick me up on my long drive! I highly recommend this shop!

Nicole G.

2/5

We gave this place many opportunities. The “nitro cold brew” is not nitro, its just cold brew. Today we paid for a $7 latte from a girl who was alone on her first day and didn’t know how to properly pull shots. I basically got milk and flavor and she said the coffee was running thin. She needs to be trained more before charging those prices.

Tamara H.

5/5

The location is convenient (it was near the hotel we stayed at the night before) and we were able to fill up with gas at the same stop. The center itself was clean and trendy. It was fairly busy, but there wasn’t a line at the coffee counter.
The baristas were friendly. We ordered two 24-oz vanilla lattes with four shots of espresso. The flavor was decent, but the coffee flavor wasn’t as strong as we like; 5 shots would have been perfect.

Levi W.

5/5

Inside the hat six stop. Ice coffee is great! Friendly staff and well staffed. Quick service.