I Like Pie Bakeshop - Claremont, California

Mimi M.

I had the Banana Cream pie and it is very delicious! Sometimes anything banana cream is usually very sweet with an overpowering taste of bananas, not this pie! You won't need to down a glass of water once you're done. I ate the whole thing and only had 2 sips of coffee, it was that good! The balance of all the ingredients is perfect 👌 I highly recommend this place! I will definitely keep coming back!

Amy K.

On our way home from a road trip, I always enjoy discovering at least one special place that offers gluten-free options to stop and try. During our recent journey, we opted for I Like Pie in Claremont. Nestled in the old town area, it exuded charm and character. Parking on the street, we strolled through a quaint shopping and dining district to reach the entrance.

The bakery, though simple, had a delightful ambiance. Inside and outside seating options were available, and the selection of pies was impressive, but only two were gluten free: Key Lime and Mixed Berry. Concerned about my allergies, I inquired about the ingredients, and the staff graciously shared the information. While they take precautions, a notice indicated the possibility of cross-contamination due to the non-dedicated facility. Despite this, I decided to take a chance, and I'm glad I did. The pies, resembling more of cupcakes or muffins, were delectable. Our favorite was the Key Lime, with its perfect balance of tartness and lime flavor. The crust, with its crumbly texture and buttery taste, complemented the filling beautifully. Notably, I experienced no adverse reactions, which was a significant relief.

Although we passed on beverages during our visit, I was slightly disappointed by the lack of loose-leaf tea, as only tea bags were available. Nonetheless, the organic tea options looked promising, leaving room for a potential try on our next visit. While the prices leaned towards the higher side, the quality of the pies more than justified it. Without hesitation, we agreed that we would happily make a detour to pick up more of these delightful treats on our future drives through the area.

Annette M.

Cute little pie shop.
I love pies, and this place had a pretty good variety.
The service was great!
I had the chicken pot pie (liked) , the lemon ice box (I didn't really care for), and the mixed berry handpicked pie (liked).
I'd definitely return to try other pies.

Zen T.

Love that they have gluten free and dairy free options! Really enjoyed the gluten free berry jar pie and the pumpkin pie. Excited to come back and try more! Please make more gluten free options, like the savory chicken pot pie!

Christina C.

So delicious!!! Highly recommend! I pre-ordered multiple mini pies, savory pies, veggie hand pies and gluten free pies for a birthday/Halloween party. The ordering process was super easy in the website and the fall selection of pies was great. It’s hard to find delicious gluten free desserts and their selection of GF food is so great!!! I’ll definitely order from them again.

Arlen M. G. C.

If you want a full size pie, make sure to order (via phone or online) 48 hrs in advance. We tried the mini and jelly jar sized pies. We tried Pecan pie, S'mores and Salted Caramel. S'mores was hands down the best. Also, they are better when warmed. Overall a little pricy ($9 for a mini) but if you want something quick for dessert (and you're in the area), not a bad way to go.

Junior S.

The pies were good. Pricey, 20 dollars for two pastries. & staff seemed friendly although everyone after us was asked if they had a rewards account but I was not so didn’t like that.

Kelsey

I love this place! I was in the area and wanted to a little dessert so I stopped in. There's plenty of street parking around and a small parking lot as well. It's in a little plaza with several other restaurants and there were lots of tables for seating. The pies all looked amazing, mostly sweet pies but there were some savory as well. They also had a small selection of gluten free pies. I got the key lime, chocolate chip chess, and peaches 'n cream. They were all delicious! If I had to choose a favorite it would be the key lime, the graham cracker crust was slightly salty and the filling was smooth and tart. My sister loved the chocolate chip chess pie, which came with a tiny cookie on top. I can't recommend this place enough and I can't wait to go back.